“Our current policy ends December 31, 2023. As we approach this next year we are recommending that each church be responsible for finding their own property insurance coverage. This will give each church local autonomy to make decisions about the amount of coverage and the cost that they feel they can absorb.”

Recommended Insurance Carriers

Direct Access Companies

• Brotherhood Mutual Insurance
  (844) 400-2248
  https://www.brotherhoodmutual.com/request-a-quote/?utm_source=brotherhoodmutual.com&utm_medium=hero&utm_campaign=Homepage%20hero%20RAQ
   

• Church Mutual/ Church Mutual Select- Contact person: Becky Schwede
  (210) 326-3739

  
  

Independent Insurance Agencies

• Texas American Insurance- Contact person: Colby Shannon
  (817) 877-3101
  cshannon@txam.com
  

• Insurance One- Contact person: T. Ryan Hutchison
  210-587-6975
  ryan@insuranceoneagency.com
  https://insoneagency.com/business-insurance/specialized-business-insurance/church-insurance/
  

• American Church Group
  https://www.americanchurchgroup-texas.com/connect-with-us/request-a-quote/
  

• United Methodist Insurance Program (powered by Sovereign Insurance Group).
  Website: Insurance for United Methodist Churches (uminsure.org)
  Phone: (484) 654-3380
  Email: umi@sovinsurance.com

Resources

Texas Dept. of Insurance helpful tips on choosing an insurance agent or carrier
https://www.tdi.texas.gov/tips/find-an-agent.html

GuideOne (access via independent agent)
(877) 448-4331
https://www.guideone.com/quote-request?product_line=Religious%20Organizations